“BREAKING NEWS” Everton VAR Drama Explained: The Real Reason Thierno Barry’s Goal Was Disallowed

Why Thierno Barry’s Second Everton Goal Was Ruled Out

Thierno Barry thought he had doubled Everton’s advantage against Ipswich Town when he headed the ball into the net in the 59th minute, but the goal was eventually disallowed following a VAR review.

Barry had already played a decisive role in Everton’s opener, getting the final touch to James Tarkowski’s effort. His second goal initially appeared to stand, but the officials soon turned their attention to Brennan Johnson, who had been in an offside position during the build-up.

VAR referred the incident to referee Stuart Attwell, who was asked to assess whether Johnson had interfered with an opponent. After reviewing the footage at the pitch-side monitor, Attwell decided that Johnson’s involvement was sufficient to constitute an offside offence and overturned the goal.

As a result, Everton remained 1-0 ahead and Barry stayed on five goals for the season.

What Does the Offside Law Say?

Being in an offside position does not automatically mean a player has committed an offence.

Under Law 11 of the IFAB Laws of the Game, an attacking player can only be penalised if they become involved in active play from an offside position, including by interfering with an opponent.

That was the key issue Attwell had to consider. There was no dispute over Johnson’s position, but the crucial question was whether his presence and involvement affected an opponent enough to warrant an offside decision.

After reviewing the footage, Attwell concluded that it did.

Moyes Questions the VAR Decision

Everton manager David Moyes was not entirely convinced by the decision after the match. The manager questioned the ruling and raised concerns about the consistency with which similar offside incidents are being interpreted.

Despite the controversy, Everton did not ultimately need Barry’s disallowed goal.

Their 11th-minute opener proved enough to secure a 1-0 victory and extend their unbeaten start to the season. Ipswich were also reduced to 10 men later in the match after Abdul Fatawu received a second yellow card for simulation.

Barry therefore had to settle for one goal, but Everton secured the result they wanted and came away with all three points.